Special thanks to Jesse Hillman at Zondervan for the review copy of this book.
I received volume 5 of the Zondervan Illustrated Bible Backgrounds Commentary on the Old Testament (ZIBBCOT) a few weeks ago. This volume covers the Minor Prophets, Job, Psalms, Proverbs, Ecclesiastes, and Song of Songs. (You may also want to read Danny’s review of volume 3). As my volume notes on the back cover, “Many today find the Old Testament a closed book.” The purpose of this series of backgrounds commentaries, then, is to illuminate the cultural context in which the Old Testament was written.
Zondervan sets out to accomplish this goal with style: thousands of pictures, maps, charts and other graphics are scattered throughout every glossy, full color page. Each chapter (which covers an entire book) opens with a page or two of historical background before proceeding to the commentary proper. As for the commentary itself, it is important to remember that this is a backgrounds commentary. As such, it should be noted that these volumes are only one (essential) piece of the library one would consult when doing sound exegesis.
The information provided in my volume largely lived up to its promises, and indeed each page serves as a great start to uncovering the cultures in which the Old Testament books are couched. I was particularly impressed by the “sidebars” that make frequent appearances. These dive deeper into a particular concept, and are immensely helpful. Consider, “To Whom do Hosea’s ‘The Ball’ and ‘The Balls’ Refer?” (pp.16-18), “The Early Days of the Persian Empire” (p.207), or “Community Lament in the Ancient Near East” (p.356). Taken with the commentary text, they are an excellent addition that is often lacking in other background commentaries. One would miss a large benefit of these commentaries if they were ignored.
Although all of the pictures are interesting, at times, I couldn’t help but feel that many of them were the commentary equivalent of eye candy. That is, they’re fun to look at, but ultimately contribute little in the way of nutritional value to the text. Do several pictures of various ancient clay tablets with indecipherable writing add much in the way of understanding? Perhaps one or two do, but the return in small, in my opinion. The graphics do add an overall sense of approachability to the text: It’s far less overwhelming to open to a colorful page full of interesting pictures than a page of plain text. They also contribute to an overall atmosphere that some may find helpful, albeit in a subconscious way. If the graphics are the nudge that an otherwise hesitant reader needs to consult a commentary, then they’re worth it. If you’re unintimidated by hundreds of pages of plain text, and you’d rather the sandwich without the parsley garnish, this may not be the commentary for you.
That said, many of the pictures are very helpful (e.g., a threshing sledge (p.60), a lamp (p.271), or the modern reconstruction of the Israelite view of the cosmos (p.264)). As for the maps and charts, they’re often worth their weight in gold.
As Danny noted, the text can sometimes be uneven, since there are so many contributors, but I doubt I’d notice if I used the commentary as a reference (as I would), rather than reading it through. Given the wide range of genre in my volume, differences should be expected anyway. In all, I was very pleased with the choice of authors (especially the excellent Duane Garrett for Ecclesiastes & Song of Songs), and what they had to say.
Finally, I should mention something about the price tag. Colorful glossy pages aren’t cheap, and neither are these volumes. All 5 are selling for $158 on Amazon, and when I consider that IVP’s 800+ page single volume OT backgrounds commentary is $24, it makes it a hard sell for me. The pictures and illustrations are indeed helpful, and I won’t deny that they set Zondervan’s commentary apart from others, but are they $134 more helpful? The answer is ultimately a subjective one that likely enjoys direct proportion to your annual book budget, and how you best engage with a book. If you have the money, and vanilla text makes you cringe, these are a great addition to your library. Pastors, teachers and students alike will certainly benefit. If you’re on a tight budget (financial, shelf space or both), and text alone will scratch most of your itch, I would look elsewhere.
Book Review: ZIBBCOT Vol.4
Posted in book review, tagged commentaries, historical background, ZIBBCOT on Monday, January 4, 2010| 3 Comments »
Special thanks to Jesse Hillman at Zondervan for the review copy of this book.
One of my Christmas presents for this season was volume 4 of the Zondervan Illustrated Bible Backgrounds Commentary on the Old Testament. I have reviewed volume 5 of this series here; my opinions of this series remain as they did in my earlier review, so a new reader may wish to consult it first. Danny has also reviewed volume 3 here.
In volume 4, ZIBBCOT offers comment on the major prophets: Isaiah, Jeremiah, Lamentations, Ezekiel, and Daniel. The volume does so with characteristic style, and is (at the risk of being redundant) quite helpful. While the comments on the text are illuminating, I should state again that some of the best portions of this volume are found in the “sidebars,” wherein a particular concept is described in greater detail. I have found these mini-articles to be most helpful in understanding the text at hand, and would even submit that they are what sets ZIBBCOT apart from other background commentaries.
Even more helpful, in my opinion, are the introductions to each book. In this volume, where the subject matter often covers large swatches of history, the extended introduction is invaluable for a broader view of the book as a whole. In some instances, the authors even include separate introductory sections on the literary setting and historical settings. The only exception here was the introduction to Ezekiel, which is far less substantial than the others; I would have preferred the more in-depth introductions such as in Isaiah or Jeremiah.
Again, I would commend this series to anybody with sufficient resources as a great help to drilling into the OT. Each author is competent, and the text is easy to understand irrespective of your level of education in biblical studies.
As a much more general note, and one perhaps better reserved for a different post, those who are less acquainted with biblical reference materials should know that this series, like any backgrounds commentary, does precisely what it advertises: illumine the cultural background of a text. There is little in the way of word studies, grammatical analysis, interpretations (past and present), examination of the text with respect to other works in the canon, etc. A (good) full fledged exegetical commentary will take into account everything that informs the meaning of a text, and will submit what that meaning is. Backgrounds commentaries will only offer, well, backgrounds. So if you are having trouble understanding Isaiah’s meaning at some point, a good backgrounds commentary (such as ZIBBCOT), will do only part of the job.
This is in no way a pejorative statement against background commentaries, much less ZIBBCOT, but it is important to understand this distinction. Without this understanding, and only the back cover to read, I would be disappointed with this series. It delivers on its purpose, but is only one step (among many) required to uncover the meaning of a text.
Read Full Post »